The short answer
No. In California the choice of auto body shop belongs to you, the vehicle owner. An insurer may recommend a shop, but it cannot require you to use it, and it has to tell you about your right to choose.
Why insurers recommend shops
Most insurers have direct repair programs: networks of shops that agree to the insurer's rates and rules in exchange for a steady flow of work. That can be convenient, but the shop's agreement is with the insurer. An independent shop works for you.
What to say to the adjuster
Tell them the shop you have chosen and give them the address. The adjuster will inspect the car at the shop or work from the shop's photos and estimate. You do not need permission, and choosing your own shop does not reduce what the policy owes you for a proper repair.
What happens when the estimates differ
The insurer's first estimate is usually written from photos. Once the car is taken apart, hidden damage is documented and sent to the insurer as a supplement. This is routine and it is how most repairs end up fully paid.
How we handle it
At VR Auto Collision Center we accept claims from every insurer. Give us your claim number and we take over the calls, the photos and the supplements.

